Friday, April 6, 2018

To Hit....Or Not To Hit.






(Please Note: This article is for entertainment purposes only)
I live in a rural area, in the mountains of Arizona, and one thing that is a constant here, along with cold winters, are animals. Animal crossing signs are as ubiquitous here as street lights would be in any big city. The problem can be as small as a couple of animals walking along the side of the road inside the town limits, or much larger. A good example of larger was when some friends and I were coming back from Flagstaff, on a well-travelled back road in April of 2016. We had only been outside of Flagstaff for about a half hour at around 5 or 6 in the evening, when animals started to be seen on both sides of the road. And by animals I don’t mean squirrels or rabbits. I mean 500 to 800 pound elk, like the example in the top picture. I instantly slowed down, but the constant sight, mile after mile of animal silhouettes and pairs of eyes glowing on either side of the road is still the most terrifying thing I’ve ever been through while driving. Before it was done, we had driven through an elk herd that was thirty to fifty miles long. Had one of them decided to spook and bolt in to the road, they would have easily flattened the SUV we were in. How you decide whether to hit the animal, or avoid it, is the subject of today’s article.

As you might know if you are a veteran reader of this blog, I used to be a test driver for GM at their proving grounds in Mesa, Arizona. During driver training, we were told one thing when it came to animals: if one got in your way...hit it. Don’t avoid it, don’t swerve, don’t try and protect it. Send it to the next life. Why would the instructor tell us that? It’s because you are likely to do less damage to yourself by hitting the animal, then you are by swerving to avoid it. If you hit the animal, you kill the animal, and maybe destroy the front of your car, but if everyone in the car is seatbelted properly, and the air bags work, the injuries to the people inside will be minor. If you swerve to avoid the animal, you risk losing control of the car, which means that maybe you roll the car, or maybe you end up out of control, hitting the side or the rear of the car, potentially causing much more damage to the people inside. He was right for the most part, as we will begin discussing now.

The first step that any driver needs to take when in country that animals live or cross close by, is to not ignore the animal crossing signs, and keep your speed at the limit, or even below if it’s dark. This will give you the greatest chance to avoid contact with the animal, because if you are going slowly, or relatively slowly, you’ll have more time, and less speed to scrub off if you can take evasive action because of the animal. So the first step is to slow down inside animal crossing zones. And yes, some of these zones, like the ones by my house, can be up to twenty miles long.  That will mean going  a long time at the speed limit or lower. But I think you’ll agree that a longer trip is worth it if it means getting to where you are going alive.

The next step is to turn your focus all the way up when in these zones. Don’t get complacent, don’t turn your favorite music up, slouch in the driver’s seat, and pretend that you are on the freeway. You need to be intensely focused not only on the road, but on the roadsides as well, especially if you are driving through valleys or places where an animal could easily get on to the road from the area next to it. You must treat these areas like people are told to treat guns. Just as a gun is to be treated as if it is always loaded, an animal crossing zone needs to be treated as if it isn’t a matter of if an animal crosses, but when the animal crosses, and you as a driver need to have that kind of awareness to survive.

Now to the crux of the matter. Should you follow the GM driving instructor’s advice, and always hit the animal, or are there times where trying to avoid it would be OK? This is all going to depend on the road conditions, and your speed. If you are going pretty fast, and an elk or a deer dart out in front of you, you have to be able to figure out what would be more dangerous: you hitting the animal, or you losing control because you swerved out of the way to avoid the animal. In this case, it’s not even close. If you are going fast, and the animal comes out quickly…hit it. It is the safest thing for you, because it is the only solution that limits the danger to you. If you swerve at high speeds, especially if it’s dark, your chances of skidding and losing control are huge. This could mean much more dangerous situations than hitting an animal.
Other things that need to be taken in to account are how wide the road is, whether it’s dry or not, whether or not there’s traffic coming towards you and behind you, and if the animal is moving.  If you are in a situation where you are on a tight two lane road with traffic, and an animal comes out, you can try to steer around him but only slightly. If he is taking up most of the road, hit him. Hitting the animal is much safer for you. Of course, this assumes that you are going at a speed that is too high to be able to stop in time after you see the animal. Of course, not hitting the animal is always best, and I do advise that whenever possible. But if the road is too narrow, and you don’t have enough time, hitting the animal is the best bet.

Now in the last paragraph, I did mention steering slightly to try and miss the animal. Some animals, like deer, will freeze when hit with a bright light. If a deer does that and freezes in the middle of the road, and the deer is far enough away and you are going at a slow enough speed that you see that you can safely steer around the deer to the right, with road conditions that allow that to be done safely, do it. Then if it’s safe, get out and try and shoo the deer off of the road so that it’s not a menace to anyone else. (A quick tip I read is that flashing your high beams at the deer a few times sometimes works to wake the deer up and get it to move again.) Notice though, in this scenario, the deer was far enough in the road where a driver could steer around it, the driver noticed it far enough ahead to take avoiding action, and the driver was going at a slow enough speed to take that action. That is why steering around it can be possibly advised in this case. But again, if the animal comes out of nowhere, and you are at a high rate of speed, you have no choice but to hit it.

I am an English teacher, and on an interesting note, this subject has been tackled by poetry. The poem is travelling through the Dark, by William Stafford (found on the Poetry Foundation’s site):

Traveling through the Dark
Traveling through the dark I found a deer
dead on the edge of the Wilson River road.
It is usually best to roll them into the canyon:
that road is narrow; to swerve might make more dead.

By glow of the tail-light I stumbled back of the car
and stood by the heap, a doe, a recent killing;
she had stiffened already, almost cold.
I dragged her off; she was large in the belly.

My fingers touching her side brought me the reason—
her side was warm; her fawn lay there waiting,
alive, still, never to be born.
Beside that mountain road I hesitated.

The car aimed ahead its lowered parking lights;
under the hood purred the steady engine.
I stood in the glare of the warm exhaust turning red;
around our group I could hear the wilderness listen.

I thought hard for us all—my only swerving—,
then pushed her over the edge into the river.

Now apart from being an English teacher, and someone who loves poetry, why did I include this poem here? Simply because this person has the right mindset, and acts properly in the face of this situation. First off, the person recognizes the danger of swerving around something on the road, and how that could lead to a loss of control, and a worse accident. Next the person sees the danger of the dead animal, and that someone could swerve to avoid it, and get in to an accident because of the dead deer. Lastly, the person takes action when and where they can, and they roll the deer in to the river, taking care of the danger.

We coexist with animals on this planet, and even though we have become nice and comfy in our wooden and concrete cocoons, the animals are out there, and it helps to realize that we are on their turf when we are driving though an animal crossing, not the other way around.

Remember, the golden rule when it comes to dealing with animal strikes is that it’s better to hit the animal than to try and swerve around it and lose control of the car. But if the animal is far enough ahead, and you are going slowly enough, with enough room, you could potentially avoid the animal. But you must take in to account traffic and the road conditions before you make the decision. What’s most important is to always stay focused while driving in animal crossing country, and not take the signs or the warnings lightly. Do this, and your chances of an animal strike go down significantly. Until next time…






No comments:

Post a Comment